wiki:NDGRoom101Meeting

Version 3 (modified by mpritcha, 11 years ago) (diff)

--

NDG "Room 101" Meeting

Meeting to remind ourselves of what we have, why, & what we have learned along the way.

Intro from Matt

  • Good opportunity to see where we are & look at improving the way we do things.
  • Room 101 ...ok, not quite. We're not going to vote for our least favourite components & see them disappear. In reality, design & development decisions have already been made, often for good reason (but it's worth reminding ourselves what those were & seeing if we're happy with the decision-making process ...not just on this project).
  • NDG took some excursions down some blind alleys. Did we learn things along the way? Are there lessons to be learned from how we got down these blind alleys (without dwelling on what was down there?)

Review of current components

  • COWS
  • CSML
  • MOLES (v2+incomplete infrastructure, v3 on way)
  • Discovery (v2)
  • Security
  • Vocabserver

Suggested points for discussion for each component:

  • Overview (brief!)
    • Reminder of what it does, where it fits in
  • How did we get there?
    • Was it designed or did it grow organically?
    • (Would we do the same again, starting from scratch?)
  • SWOT
    • Strengths
      • Particular successes / things learned
      • Fitness for purpose
        • Does it do what it was specified to?
        • Does the spec meet current needs?
        • Have people been able to deploy / integrate / use it?
    • Weaknesses
      • What obstacles have been encountered?
      • Have these been overcome?
      • By satisfactory means?
    • Opportunities
      • What have we learned while building this?
      • What is the roadmap for this component?
    • Technology (...or Threats?)
      • Have we used appropriate technologies?
        • Element tree for XML procesing
        • Exist for XML databases
        • SOAP toolkits
        • WS-Security
        • Pylons
        • Postgres
      • Has development been guided too much / enough by available technology
      • Have we reinvented wheels?

Going forward

What new requirements lie ahead

  • NDG MSI
  • ??

Sum up