Ignore:
Timestamp:
14/11/16 22:33:36 (4 years ago)
Author:
mjuckes
Message:

candidate

File:
1 edited

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
  • CMIP6dreqbuild/trunk/src/framework/out/supplement_20150731.xml

    r860 r861  
    22<document xmlns="urn:w3id.org:cmip6.dreq.dreq:a" xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:pav="http://purl.org/pav/2.3" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:noNamespaceSchemaLocation="out/dreqSchema.xsd"> 
    33<prologue> 
    4 <dc:title>CMIP6 Data Request Supplement [01.beta.41]</dc:title> 
     4<dc:title>CMIP6 Data Request Supplement [01.beta.42]</dc:title> 
    55<dc:description>The CMIP6 Data Request will specify the variables requested for the CMIP6 archive, and the detail the experiments and time slices for which they are required.</dc:description> 
    66<dc:creator>Martin Juckes</dc:creator> 
    7 <dc:date>2016-11-10</dc:date> 
    8 <pav:version>01.beta.41</pav:version> 
     7<dc:date>2016-11-14</dc:date> 
     8<pav:version>01.beta.42</pav:version> 
    99</prologue> 
    1010<main> 
    1111<qcranges id="" label="qcranges" title="Quality Control Ranges" uid="SECTION:qcranges" useClass="vocab"> 
    1212<!-- <info srcType="dummy" srcRef="ptxt.py">Dummy entries</info> --> 
    13 <item comment="" label="Amon-ci" ok_max_mean_abs_status="suggested" ok_min_mean_abs="0.9" ok_min_mean_abs_status="suggested" prov="CMIP5 data" title="Guide ranges for ci (table Amon)" uid="ad053490-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="1.001" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.001" valid_min_status="robust" vid="baaa3984-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    14 <item comment="" label="Amon-sci" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="0.9" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for sci (table Amon)" uid="ad066e32-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="1.001" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.001" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab6d180-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    15 <item comment="One CMIP5 model is an outlier in mean abs values, being a factor 1000 out: a clear scaling error. Many models exceed the CMIP5 max: relaxed significantly to allow for further increase in modelled convective activity" label="Amon-prc" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="4e-05" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for prc (table Amon)" uid="ad084f72-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="0.0015" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-1e-06" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab3f8a2-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    16 <item comment="" label="Amon-tas" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="295.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for tas (table Amon)" uid="ad0988ce-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="350.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="170.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab9237c-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    17 <item comment="CMIP5 values too limited: expanded here." label="Amon-rsuscs" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="90.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for rsuscs (table Amon)" uid="ad0ad1e8-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="480.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.1" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab670b4-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    18 <item comment="CMIP5 values too restrictive .. resolution dependent extremes expected .. generous extension of range" label="Amon-uas" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="10.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for uas (table Amon)" uid="ad0b382c-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="80.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-80.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="babb67c2-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    19 <item comment="CMIP5 table max/min values OK apart from one outlier; mean abs values too tight" label="Amon-huss" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="0.012" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for huss (table Amon)" uid="ad0b75da-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="0.03" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="0.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab01dfe-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    20 <item comment="" label="Amon-hfss" ok_max_mean_abs_status="suggested" ok_min_mean_abs="38.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="suggested" prov="" title="Guide ranges for hfss (table Amon)" uid="ad0bb298-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="1200.0" valid_max_status="suggested" valid_min="-400.0" valid_min_status="suggested" vid="baaf86a0-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    21 <item comment="" label="Amon-rlutcs" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="270.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for rlutcs (table Amon)" uid="ad0bdeee-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="390.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="65.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab5bcdc-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    22 <item comment="All models in CMIP5 range, but close to max: relaxed slightly" label="Amon-prw" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="26.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for prw (table Amon)" uid="ad0c1562-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="90.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="0.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab45df6-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    23 <item comment="CMIP5 models all consistent; several exceed CMOR table max;" label="Amon-prsn" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="8e-06" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for prsn (table Amon)" uid="ad0c54c8-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="0.0008" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-1e-06" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab42b88-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    24 <item comment="" label="Amon-rldscs" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="310.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for rldscs (table Amon)" uid="ad0c92bc-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="550.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="25.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab5540e-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    25 <item comment="Only 3 models .. positive definate in CMIP5, but may turn negative in CMIP6" label="Amon-fco2antt" ok_max_mean_abs_status="tentative" ok_min_mean_abs="1e-09" ok_min_mean_abs_status="tentative" prov="" title="Guide ranges for fco2antt (table Amon)" uid="ad0cc868-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="2e-07" valid_max_status="tentative" valid_min="-1e-07" valid_min_status="suggested" vid="baaddada-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    26 <item comment="CMIP5 table values OK, but expanded slightly here to allow for greater spatial and scenario variability" label="Amon-pr" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="4e-05" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for pr (table Amon)" uid="ad0cf5f4-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="0.0015" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-1e-06" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab3cb52-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    27 <item comment="CMIP5 values OK .. abs range tightened slightly" label="Amon-ps" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="100000.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for ps (table Amon)" uid="ad0d2de4-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="112000.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="47500.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab47b56-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    28 <item comment="" label="Amon-rlus" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="380.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for rlus (table Amon)" uid="ad0d5e2c-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="660.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="43.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab578d0-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    29 <item comment="Relaxed mean abs slightly" label="Amon-rlds" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="330.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="CMIP5 data" title="Guide ranges for rlds (table Amon)" uid="ad0d931a-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="520.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="30.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab52da8-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    30 <item comment="" label="Amon-fco2nat" ok_max_mean_abs_status="suggested" ok_min_mean_abs="1e-07" ok_min_mean_abs_status="suggested" prov="" title="Guide ranges for fco2nat (table Amon)" uid="ad0ddabe-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="2e-06" valid_max_status="suggested" valid_min="-2e-05" valid_min_status="suggested" vid="baaded68-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    31 <item comment="" label="Amon-ts" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="295.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for ts (table Amon)" uid="ad0e089a-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="340.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="170.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="babaef0e-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    32 <item comment="" label="Amon-clt" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="85.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="CMIP5 request/data" title="Guide ranges for clt (table Amon)" uid="ad0e4184-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="100.001" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.001" valid_min_status="robust" vid="baaad7e0-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    33 <item comment="CMIP5 values too restrictive .. resolution dependent extremes expected .. generous extension of range" label="Amon-vas" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="10.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for vas (table Amon)" uid="ad0e723a-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="80.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-80.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="babbcd34-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    34 <item comment="CMIP5 values OK: one model has clear outliers not picked up by the limits: could be tightened?" label="Amon-psl" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="106000.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for psl (table Amon)" uid="ad0eaf7a-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="109000.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="91000.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab48ce0-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    35 <item comment="" label="Amon-rlut" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="305.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for rlut (table Amon)" uid="ad0edd24-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="385.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="65.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab5aad0-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    36 <item comment="" label="Amon-hurs" ok_max_mean_abs_status="suggested" ok_min_mean_abs="99.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="suggested" prov="CMIP5 data" title="Guide ranges for hurs (table Amon)" uid="ad0f1230-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="100.001" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.001" valid_min_status="robust" vid="baaff41e-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    37 <item comment="CMIP5 values too limited: expanded here." label="Amon-rsds" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="200.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for rsds (table Amon)" uid="ad0f4d36-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="550.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.1" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab5e1b2-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    38 <item comment="One model family in CMIP5 (NASA-GISS) has substantially larger values than all others. Broad limits set here to encompass all values." label="Amon-sbl" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="0.0001" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for sbl (table Amon)" uid="ad0f784c-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="0.001" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.0005" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab6b948-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    39 <item comment="CMIP5 values too limited: expanded here." label="Amon-rtmt" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="150.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for rtmt (table Amon)" uid="ad0fadc6-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="250.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-250.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab6a91c-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    40 <item comment="Convection can occur at any level in the atmosphere." label="Amon-cct" ok_max_mean_abs_status="suggested" ok_min_mean_abs="100000.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="suggested" prov="CMIP6 discussion" title="Guide ranges for cct (table Amon)" uid="ad0fd986-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="115000.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="0.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="baa96a0e-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    41 <item comment="Two models  (one institution) in CMIP5 were under this valid_min, but acknowledged this as an error." label="Amon-rsutcs" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="120.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for rsutcs (table Amon)" uid="ad100e6a-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="480.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.1" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab69c06-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    42 <item comment="Maximum in CMIP5 archive 28 ... but resolution dependent." label="Amon-sfcWind" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="15.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for sfcWind (table Amon)" uid="ad104592-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="80.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="0.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab6f494-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    43 <item comment="CMIP5 values exceeded ... appear to have been too restrictive" label="Amon-tauv" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="0.2" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for tauv (table Amon)" uid="ad107576-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="10.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-10.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab9888a-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    44 <item comment="" label="Amon-tasmin" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="290.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for tasmin (table Amon)" uid="ad10ae10-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="345.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="165.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab955ea-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    45 <item comment="CMIP5 values exceeded ... appear to have been too restrictive" label="Amon-tauu" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="0.2" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for tauu (table Amon)" uid="ad10dba6-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="10.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-10.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab96cc4-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    46 <item comment="" label="Amon-tasmax" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="300.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for tasmax (table Amon)" uid="ad1110c6-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="355.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="175.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab942a8-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    47 <item comment="CMIP5 values too limited: expanded here." label="Amon-rsus" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="90.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for rsus (table Amon)" uid="ad113e48-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="480.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.1" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab6537c-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    48 <item comment="" label="Amon-hfls" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="80.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="CMIP5 data" title="Guide ranges for hfls (table Amon)" uid="ad11758e-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="850.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-90.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="baaefe2e-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    49 <item comment="Two models  (one institution) in CMIP5 were under this valid_min, but acknowledged this as an error." label="Amon-rsut" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="160.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for rsut (table Amon)" uid="ad11a8f6-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="480.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.1" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab68ebe-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    50 <item comment="Convection can occur at any level in the atmosphere." label="Amon-ccb" ok_max_mean_abs_status="suggested" ok_min_mean_abs="100000.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="suggested" prov="CMIP6 discussion" title="Guide ranges for ccb (table Amon)" uid="ad11d81c-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="115000.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="0.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="baa92652-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    51 <item comment="" label="day-clt" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="90.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for clt (table day)" uid="ad121840-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" url="http://w3id.org/cmip6dr/ranges/day_clt.html" valid_max="100.001" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.001" valid_min_status="robust" vid="baaace4e-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    52 <item comment="" label="day-hfss" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="60.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for hfss (table day)" uid="ad1247b6-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="2000.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-1000.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="baaf91cc-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    53 <item comment="" label="day-hfls" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="110.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for hfls (table day)" uid="ad127f60-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="1800.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-400.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="baaf0a9a-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    54 <item comment="" label="Omon-agessc" ok_max_mean_abs_status="suggested" ok_min_mean_abs="5000.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="suggested" prov="" title="Guide ranges for agessc (table Omon)" uid="ad12b782-a73a-11e6-b231-5404a60d96b5" valid_max="20000.0" valid_max_status="suggested" valid_min="-0.001" valid_min_status="robust" vid="baa56de6-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     13<item comment="" label="Amon-ci" ok_max_mean_abs_status="suggested" ok_min_mean_abs="0.9" ok_min_mean_abs_status="suggested" prov="CMIP5 data" title="Guide ranges for ci (table Amon)" uid="05b7d84a-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="1.001" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.001" valid_min_status="robust" vid="baaa3984-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     14<item comment="" label="Amon-sci" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="0.9" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for sci (table Amon)" uid="05b9e04a-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="1.001" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.001" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab6d180-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     15<item comment="One CMIP5 model is an outlier in mean abs values, being a factor 1000 out: a clear scaling error. Many models exceed the CMIP5 max: relaxed significantly to allow for further increase in modelled convective activity" label="Amon-prc" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="4e-05" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for prc (table Amon)" uid="05baf46c-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="0.0015" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-1e-06" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab3f8a2-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     16<item comment="" label="Amon-tas" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="295.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for tas (table Amon)" uid="05bc150e-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="350.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="170.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab9237c-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     17<item comment="CMIP5 values too limited: expanded here." label="Amon-rsuscs" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="90.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for rsuscs (table Amon)" uid="05bd2e12-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="480.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.1" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab670b4-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     18<item comment="CMIP5 values too restrictive .. resolution dependent extremes expected .. generous extension of range" label="Amon-uas" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="10.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for uas (table Amon)" uid="05bd8844-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="80.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-80.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="babb67c2-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     19<item comment="CMIP5 table max/min values OK apart from one outlier; mean abs values too tight" label="Amon-huss" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="0.012" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for huss (table Amon)" uid="05bdc02a-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="0.03" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="0.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab01dfe-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     20<item comment="" label="Amon-hfss" ok_max_mean_abs_status="suggested" ok_min_mean_abs="38.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="suggested" prov="" title="Guide ranges for hfss (table Amon)" uid="05bdefdc-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="1200.0" valid_max_status="suggested" valid_min="-400.0" valid_min_status="suggested" vid="baaf86a0-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     21<item comment="" label="Amon-rlutcs" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="270.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for rlutcs (table Amon)" uid="05be1a16-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="390.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="65.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab5bcdc-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     22<item comment="All models in CMIP5 range, but close to max: relaxed slightly" label="Amon-prw" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="26.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for prw (table Amon)" uid="05be3c94-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="90.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="0.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab45df6-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     23<item comment="CMIP5 models all consistent; several exceed CMOR table max;" label="Amon-prsn" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="8e-06" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for prsn (table Amon)" uid="05be68f4-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="0.0008" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-1e-06" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab42b88-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     24<item comment="" label="Amon-rldscs" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="310.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for rldscs (table Amon)" uid="05be8e10-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="550.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="25.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab5540e-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     25<item comment="Only 3 models .. positive definate in CMIP5, but may turn negative in CMIP6" label="Amon-fco2antt" ok_max_mean_abs_status="tentative" ok_min_mean_abs="1e-09" ok_min_mean_abs_status="tentative" prov="" title="Guide ranges for fco2antt (table Amon)" uid="05beb93a-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="2e-07" valid_max_status="tentative" valid_min="-1e-07" valid_min_status="suggested" vid="baaddada-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     26<item comment="CMIP5 table values OK, but expanded slightly here to allow for greater spatial and scenario variability" label="Amon-pr" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="4e-05" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for pr (table Amon)" uid="05bee428-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="0.0015" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-1e-06" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab3cb52-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     27<item comment="CMIP5 values OK .. abs range tightened slightly" label="Amon-ps" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="100000.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for ps (table Amon)" uid="05bf08f4-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="112000.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="47500.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab47b56-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     28<item comment="" label="Amon-rlus" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="380.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for rlus (table Amon)" uid="05bf3202-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="660.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="43.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab578d0-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     29<item comment="Relaxed mean abs slightly" label="Amon-rlds" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="330.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="CMIP5 data" title="Guide ranges for rlds (table Amon)" uid="05bf566a-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="520.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="30.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab52da8-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     30<item comment="" label="Amon-fco2nat" ok_max_mean_abs_status="suggested" ok_min_mean_abs="1e-07" ok_min_mean_abs_status="suggested" prov="" title="Guide ranges for fco2nat (table Amon)" uid="05bf81ee-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="2e-06" valid_max_status="suggested" valid_min="-2e-05" valid_min_status="suggested" vid="baaded68-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     31<item comment="" label="Amon-ts" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="295.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for ts (table Amon)" uid="05bfaa02-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="340.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="170.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="babaef0e-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     32<item comment="" label="Amon-clt" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="85.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="CMIP5 request/data" title="Guide ranges for clt (table Amon)" uid="05bfd536-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="100.001" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.001" valid_min_status="robust" vid="baaad7e0-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     33<item comment="CMIP5 values too restrictive .. resolution dependent extremes expected .. generous extension of range" label="Amon-vas" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="10.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for vas (table Amon)" uid="05c000a6-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="80.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-80.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="babbcd34-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     34<item comment="CMIP5 values OK: one model has clear outliers not picked up by the limits: could be tightened?" label="Amon-psl" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="106000.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for psl (table Amon)" uid="05c02356-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="109000.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="91000.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab48ce0-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     35<item comment="" label="Amon-rlut" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="305.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for rlut (table Amon)" uid="05c056fa-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="385.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="65.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab5aad0-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     36<item comment="" label="Amon-hurs" ok_max_mean_abs_status="suggested" ok_min_mean_abs="99.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="suggested" prov="CMIP5 data" title="Guide ranges for hurs (table Amon)" uid="05c07afe-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="100.001" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.001" valid_min_status="robust" vid="baaff41e-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     37<item comment="CMIP5 values too limited: expanded here." label="Amon-rsds" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="200.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for rsds (table Amon)" uid="05c0a696-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="550.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.1" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab5e1b2-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     38<item comment="One model family in CMIP5 (NASA-GISS) has substantially larger values than all others. Broad limits set here to encompass all values." label="Amon-sbl" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="0.0001" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for sbl (table Amon)" uid="05c0d206-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="0.001" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.0005" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab6b948-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     39<item comment="CMIP5 values too limited: expanded here." label="Amon-rtmt" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="150.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for rtmt (table Amon)" uid="05c0f628-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="250.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-250.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab6a91c-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     40<item comment="Convection can occur at any level in the atmosphere." label="Amon-cct" ok_max_mean_abs_status="suggested" ok_min_mean_abs="100000.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="suggested" prov="CMIP6 discussion" title="Guide ranges for cct (table Amon)" uid="05c12170-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="115000.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="0.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="baa96a0e-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     41<item comment="Two models  (one institution) in CMIP5 were under this valid_min, but acknowledged this as an error." label="Amon-rsutcs" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="120.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for rsutcs (table Amon)" uid="05c145c4-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="480.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.1" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab69c06-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     42<item comment="Maximum in CMIP5 archive 28 ... but resolution dependent." label="Amon-sfcWind" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="15.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for sfcWind (table Amon)" uid="05c1715c-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="80.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="0.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab6f494-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     43<item comment="CMIP5 values exceeded ... appear to have been too restrictive" label="Amon-tauv" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="0.2" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for tauv (table Amon)" uid="05c19470-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="10.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-10.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab9888a-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     44<item comment="" label="Amon-tasmin" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="290.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for tasmin (table Amon)" uid="05c1bed2-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="345.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="165.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab955ea-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     45<item comment="CMIP5 values exceeded ... appear to have been too restrictive" label="Amon-tauu" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="0.2" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for tauu (table Amon)" uid="05c1eb1e-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="10.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-10.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab96cc4-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     46<item comment="" label="Amon-tasmax" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="300.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for tasmax (table Amon)" uid="05c21120-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="355.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="175.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab942a8-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     47<item comment="CMIP5 values too limited: expanded here." label="Amon-rsus" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="90.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for rsus (table Amon)" uid="05c23c9a-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="480.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.1" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab6537c-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     48<item comment="" label="Amon-hfls" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="80.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="CMIP5 data" title="Guide ranges for hfls (table Amon)" uid="05c26102-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="850.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-90.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="baaefe2e-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     49<item comment="Two models  (one institution) in CMIP5 were under this valid_min, but acknowledged this as an error." label="Amon-rsut" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="160.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for rsut (table Amon)" uid="05c28d6c-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="480.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.1" valid_min_status="robust" vid="bab68ebe-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     50<item comment="Convection can occur at any level in the atmosphere." label="Amon-ccb" ok_max_mean_abs_status="suggested" ok_min_mean_abs="100000.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="suggested" prov="CMIP6 discussion" title="Guide ranges for ccb (table Amon)" uid="05c2b904-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="115000.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="0.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="baa92652-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     51<item comment="" label="day-clt" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="90.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for clt (table day)" uid="05c2dbfa-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" url="http://w3id.org/cmip6dr/ranges/day_clt.html" valid_max="100.001" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-0.001" valid_min_status="robust" vid="baaace4e-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     52<item comment="" label="day-hfss" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="60.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for hfss (table day)" uid="05c3077e-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="2000.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-1000.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="baaf91cc-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     53<item comment="" label="day-hfls" ok_max_mean_abs_status="robust" ok_min_mean_abs="110.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="robust" prov="" title="Guide ranges for hfls (table day)" uid="05c32bdc-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="1800.0" valid_max_status="robust" valid_min="-400.0" valid_min_status="robust" vid="baaf0a9a-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
     54<item comment="" label="Omon-agessc" ok_max_mean_abs_status="suggested" ok_min_mean_abs="5000.0" ok_min_mean_abs_status="suggested" prov="" title="Guide ranges for agessc (table Omon)" uid="05c35940-aaba-11e6-81df-ac72891c3257" valid_max="20000.0" valid_max_status="suggested" valid_min="-0.001" valid_min_status="robust" vid="baa56de6-e5dd-11e5-8482-ac72891c3257"/> 
    5555</qcranges> 
    5656<places id="" label="places" title="Places, States or Reservoirs" uid="SECTION:places" useClass="vocab"> 
Note: See TracChangeset for help on using the changeset viewer.